RDL
Homepage

Table of
Contents

Document
Information

CHAPTER 8

EVALUATION

This chapter describes evaluation principles and grading considerations. It also contains guidelines for conducting the hands-on performance test component of the APART and proficiency, NVD standardization, postmishap, medical, no-notice, and commander's evaluations. The flight evaluation is a primary means of assessing flight standardization and crew member proficiency. It is, therefore, a key part of Army aviation standardization.

Section I. Evaluation Principles and Grading Considerations

8-1. EVALUATION PRINCIPLES

8-2. GRADING CONSIDERATIONS

NOTE: During an evaluation, a task iteration performed in a more demanding mode of flight may suffice for an iteration performed in a less demanding mode of flight. The commander determines which mode of flight is more demanding.

Section II. Evaluation Guidelines

8-3. CREW MEMBER AND CREW FLIGHT EVALUATION

The flight evaluation determines the crew member's ability to perform appropriate tasks. It is administered for the initial designation to the assigned duty position, when required, and at periodic intervals per AR 95-1. The evaluation sequence consists of four phases. Phases 2 and 3 contain specific guidelines for conducting various aviation missions. The evaluator is the final authority on the amount of time devoted to each phase. If the evaluation is for an evaluator or a unit trainer, the recommended procedure is for the evaluator to reverse roles with the examinee during Phases 1, 2, and 3. When the evaluator uses this technique, he must ensure that the examinee understands how the role reversal will be conducted and when it will be in effect. Initial validation of an evaluator's orders at a new duty station will be conducted in the aircraft.

NOTE 1: If the evaluation is for an IP, SP, IE, or ME, the evaluator must explain that he will evaluate the examinee's ability to apply the learning and teaching process outlined in the Instructor's Handbook.

NOTE 2: For UTs, the evaluation will include special emphasis on the examinee's performance in those areas in which UT duties are performed. The evaluation should ensure that the examinee can safely and effectively perform UT duties.

NOTE: TM 55-1520-238-10 and local directives contain additional crew briefing requirements.

8-4. BATTLE-ROSTERED CREW EVALUATION

8-5. PROFICIENCY FLIGHT EVALUATION

This evaluation is conducted per AR 95-1. After the evaluation, the IP or SP will debrief the examinee or crew and complete DA Forms 4507-R, 4507-2-R (if used), 5051-11-R (if used), 5882-R, and 7121-R per instructions in Chapter 9.

8-6. NVS STANDARDIZATION FLIGHT EVALUATION

This evaluation is conducted during the examinee's APART period. The examinee is evaluated at night in the aircraft in his designated crew station. After the evaluation, the IP or SP will debrief the examinee and complete DA Forms 4507-R, 4507-2-R (if used), and 5882-R per instructions in Chapter 9.

8-7. ANNUAL NVG STANDARDIZATION FLIGHT EVALUATION

This evaluation is conducted per TC 1-210. After the evaluation, the IP or SP will debrief the examinee and complete DA Forms 4507-R, 4507-2-R (if used), and 5882-R per instructions in Chapter 9.

8-8. POSTMISHAP FLIGHT EVALUATION

This evaluation is required by AR 95-1. After the evaluation, the IP or SP will debrief the examinee and complete DA Forms 4507-R, 4507-2-R (if used), 5051-11-R (if used), and 5882-R per instructions in Chapter 9.

8-9. MEDICAL FLIGHT EVALUATION

This evaluation is conducted per AR 95-1. The IP or SP, on the recommendation of the flight surgeon, will require the examinee to perform a series of tasks most affected by the examinee's disability. The evaluation should measure the examinee's potential to perform ATM tasks despite his disability. It should not be based on current proficiency.

8-10. NO-NOTICE EVALUATION

This evaluation is conducted per TC 1-210. After the evaluation, the evaluator will debrief the examinee or crew and complete DA Forms 4507-R, 4507-2-R (if used), 5051-11-R (if used), 5882-R, and 7121-R per instructions in Chapter 9.

8-11. COMMANDER'S EVALUATION

This evaluation is conducted per TC 1-210. After the evaluation, the evaluator will debrief the examinee and complete DA Forms 4507-R, 4507-2-R (if used), 5051-11-R (if used), and 5882-R per instructions in Chapter 9.